Discount Products and Customer Reviews
Dungeons and Dragons Core Rulebook Gift Set, 4th Edition
|
| ||||||||
 A new generation of a classic game At first I was a bit skeptical about this new edition after reading a lot of the material coming from the forums and seasoned veterans of table top RPGs, but when I picked it up and tried it out for myself, I was pleasantly surprised. A lot of the fears people had about the game being over the top action is somewhat unfounded, if anything its quite the opposite. I whipped up a quick adventure about a mind flayer controlling town politics and went at it. The first thing I noticed was that the players spent much less time looking up modifiers and rolling dice then they did interacting with the game world. With the skills being simplified a bit, it made the game so much easier to get to the bottom of things and actually, dare I say it, role-play. I threw in a complex skill challenge and was impressed out how smooth and excited the players were just interacting with the local thieves guild, which is something I havent seen in awhile. Eventually the players were forced in combat. I remember in 3.x there seemed to be a formula for combat depending on the type of enemy involved. That exists to a degree, but combat is so much smoother than it used to be. The abilities that the classes get really mesh well and the new system is so much easier. Instead of 4 steps for a grapple its one! The players acted much more tactically and really got into the nitty gritty only relying on the dice when it was completely necessary. Throw in a few action phrases and its a much more focused game play experience. The dungeon masters guide and monster manual feel like theyve been designed for ease of use as well. Some people will say the game has been dumbed down, and I know what they mean. I felt that way until I saw the game in action and realized the new strategic depth that was never there before. I can already see a strategy guide coming out for battle strategy. Overall I would recommend this product to both veterans and new people to the hobby-both for its new ease of use and re-imagining of a classic hobby.  A radical change of pace I had the opportunity to do a complete read-through of the PHB, and I'm really excited about what I saw. I didn't have time to look through the DMG or MM. The meteoric rise of Massively Multiplayer RPGs has created a unprecedentedly-large case study about what works for class advancement and balance. When I was first looking through the promotional material I noticed concepts from the MMO space cropping up: defender(tank), striker(dps), controller, and leader(support). I was initially disappointed by this, but the more I thought about it the more the idea began to grow on me. Every class now has a role within the group so there's no question about what each character should be doing. The options for character advancement are fewer than previous versions. Whereas 3.x gave you the tools to create just about any type of character, that's not so much the case in 4. For the advanced players who enjoyed making odd concept characters, this is going to be their primary gripe with the system. I'm talking, frothing-at-the-mouth, storm-the-Bastille forum fanboy crazy. For the rest of the players, who just want to _play_, it's going to be great. You don't have to worry about some powergamer creating a monstrosity of character that starts an arms race with the DM. Even if you don't have a powergamer around, there's very little chance of a player accidentally creating a character that's isn't effective in the group. What excites me as a player is the fact that you get something cool at every level. It was always kind of boring as a fighter in 3.x: "Another feat. Yawn. This'll be interesting in another dozen levels when my build finally comes together". In 4e, I get something new to play with each time. What excites me as a DM is that my life got easier. There aren't any "Attack of opportunity" or "grapple" nightmare rules like before. There's less opportunity for rule-lawyering and general powergaming. The various social skills have been streamlined, giving the DM the chance to RP with interested players, while disinterested players can just roll their way through it. What doesn't excite me is the online component. From what I've seen I don't think WotC has the staff necessary to put out quality software. Anyone remember the e-tools they touted in 2000. No? There's a reason you don't. They got delayed for _years_, and when they finally came out they were terrible, unusable even. Software development at that scale is hard and it's even harder if you're not a software development house and aren't used to managing the projects. Some people will complain that the new rules are too much like an MMO. It's their choice as to whether that's something they'll enjoy. One thing to keep in mind is this: It doesn't matter if you've been DMing for 30 years, any given MMO sees their rules exercised more in a single weekend that you've done in your career. A MMO is a crucible for finding rules that require a _minimum of human intervention_. It boils down to this: if you enjoy the act of playing with your group and the rules are an accessory, then you'll love 4e. If you enjoy playing with the rules and your group is an accessory, then you'll hate 4e.  A Step Backwards not exactly the next step in the evolution of the game. touted as a "steamlined" and "improved" re-imagining of the classic game that has been around in several incarnations over the past 30-some-odd-years; what it truly amounts to is an advanced tactical board game. much of what made the game great is stripped away in an effort to emulate mmo (massive multiplayer online) games like world of warcraft; intentionally dumbing down the game in an effort to market it to a wider demographic. elements of game play that focused on actual role-play and story telling are minimized in favor of combat. instead of taking what was good in both types of games and creating a higher, more elegant game that becomes greater than the sum of its parts, it instead is a souped up throwback to the chainmal days of d&d with mmo hidebound adhearance to mmo sensabilities. while i can appreciate that hasbro may have had the best of intentions in crafting this version of the game, it fails in the eyes of this and many other fans who have played for so many years. it plays more like other sword & sorcery genre board games (descent, runebound, world of warcraft), and may in fact be the best and finest board game in the genre. but, sadly, it is no true rpg and those who seek that out in this game will be sorely disatisfied. Cant Wait I've never known wizards of the coast to put out a bad book. Im looking very forward to recieving my box set. Their game and informational system are outstanding! Sometimes it takes a little creative tweaking on the DM's side to get rules to all work in harmony but i've heard there have been massive rule updates and a wind storm of changes. Dont forget the Artwork. Wizards of the coast's books always have the most amazing displays. The creativity and stunning beauty of their pictures are fantastic; specialy the Monster Manual, the vivid images just bring your imagination to life as you can see every detail of your monster. Dont pass up, it should be great! | |||||||||
